Here's what rhymes with reply.
dry lie try ly ply rye lye pry tri trie wry lai luy pri ripply by my high why apply die thy y buy cry fly guy imply rely tie vi hi shy sigh bi bye chi dye fi hy nigh pi pie thai thigh vie dei fry psi quae sly ty wir awry hai mai muy nai belie cy fy kai mei sy tai thei wai phi retry spry triply slier supply sky deny defy spy decry pupae sty stye turfy lanai thereby nearby whereby comply hereby alkali goodbye underlie alibi ratify terrify typify untie descry edify overlie resupply aquae bonsai deify amebae blowfly misapply barfly prettify vitrify drachmai banzais yuppify occupy modify multiply nuclei simplify verify butterfly certify gratify notify purify alveoli amplify nullify pacify rectify samurai unify beautify lullaby solidify termini amoebae codify liquefy mollify ramify vilify acidify firefly mystify ossify ultrahigh vivify horrify petrify stupefy liquify overfly scurfy shanghai refortify overbuy justify satisfy stimuli clarify qualify specify classify signify testify glorify fortify standby falsify crucify dignify mortify oversupply electrify stratify stultify calcify emulsify reunify revivify cumuli scarify versify hyperbolae mummify beatify gentrify speechify syllabify dandify identify exemplify intensify quantify diversify magnify indemnify personify demystify detoxify dragonfly preoccupy reclassify dissatisfy declassify disqualify objectify oversimplify solemnify misidentify transmogrify