Here's what rhymes with overlay.
re lay ray valet yea allay fillet ley rei lei rea roue hurray they may day way away say pay play j survey array bay clay gay gray grey k pray che hay nay prey spray weigh ballet stray tray fay fe fray slay dey hey sei sleigh whey drei jay kc payee rj tae tre wei bey bray dray flay neigh soiree brae cay fey filet shay splay sachet hooray overpay overplay trey aurae aweigh stay today delay decay essay obey okay cafe repay sway astray oj ij ok passe bj bk fj saute tj zwei parquet souffle belay moray purvey sorbet overstay reweigh spay display convey holiday betray halfway vertebrae attache bouquet cliche defray disobey faraway lamellae papillae sequelae waterway dossier emigre francais puree replay underlay alleyway crochet croquet fistulae risque fibulae giveaway hideaway inveigh throwaway airplay byplay nisei patellae prepay resurvey soubriquet stowaway toupee flyaway noway sickbay urethrae briquet caesurae layaway outplay umbrae uvulae copay misplay respray anyway everyday yesterday dismay formulae interplay portray runaway underway disarray naivete passageway protege cabaret gangway naturae nebulae societe toothache getaway lingerie maxillae scapulae sobriquet wordplay workaday caraway castaway ricochet pleurae stingray underplay medullae outstay underpay bobsleigh copulae foldaway tearaway matinee microarray breakaway straightaway carriageway salmonellae takeaway macrame roundelay cybercafe walkaway communique cabriolet penumbrae tarantulae trabeculae caravanserais companionway