Here's what rhymes with identify.
high thy vi hi shy sigh fi hy thigh vie psi hai cy fy sy thei phi by my why die lie y buy fly sky guy tie modify bi bye chi defy dye nigh pi pie spy testify thai dei fry ly notify quae rye sly ty wir awry lye mai muy nai wry kai lai luy mei tai typify wai edify sty bonsai deify stye turfy slier dandify apply dry try cry deny justify simplify certify ply underlie amplify nullify pacify pry ratify rectify tri trie belie pri terrify untie codify dignify mollify aquae mystify ossify spry amebae petrify lanai mummify prettify beatify gentrify banzais supply thereby imply nearby rely satisfy stimuli hereby specify signify verify butterfly gratify intensify purify alibi magnify unify beautify decry indemnify pupae amoebae descry liquefy mortify objectify overlie ramify acidify demystify firefly stratify stultify blowfly horrify stupefy liquify overfly scurfy versify barfly misidentify shanghai vitrify speechify overbuy yuppify reply occupy whereby clarify comply multiply nuclei qualify alkali classify exemplify glorify goodbye quantify alveoli diversify fortify samurai standby falsify lullaby solidify termini crucify personify vilify electrify retry triply ultrahigh vivify calcify emulsify misapply reunify dissatisfy scarify hyperbolae drachmai ripply solemnify oversupply resupply detoxify dragonfly declassify refortify syllabify disqualify oversimplify preoccupy revivify cumuli reclassify transmogrify