Here's what rhymes with toothfairy.
very vary fairy ferry hairy sherry harry faerie marry merry bury dairy wary cherry berry scary tarry parry nary tare barre terry wherry prairie aviary pessary necessary dietary adversary judiciary visionary estuary honorary emissary fiduciary savagery ternary canary remarry unwary bacillary breviary buffoonery apiary equerry humeri bilberry topiary plagiary sectary literary temporary missionary dictionary solitary stationary urinary cemetery pituitary sanitary unitary ancillary budgetary dysentery mercenary seminary apothecary commissary funerary itinerary obituary papillary stationery statuary cautionary luminary tutelary beriberi diversionary cassowary chokecherry nondairy military ordinary secondary secretary arbitrary customary monetary pulmonary unnecessary capillary coronary hereditary monastery sanctuary subsidiary beneficiary legendary maxillary pecuniary corollary planetary salutary sedentary veterinary culinary functionary mortuary sanguinary centenary deflationary dignitary epistolary legionary actuary dromedary huckleberry lapidary recessionary elderberry commentary evolutionary imaginary disciplinary momentary reactionary tributary discretionary inflationary probationary supernumerary unsanitary insanitary concessionary geostationary voluptuary bicentenary tercentenary contemporary revolutionary preliminary vocabulary fragmentary involuntary proprietary exclusionary confectionery expansionary eleemosynary elocutionary nonliterary uncustomary expeditionary genitourinary paramilitary nonmilitary undersecretary nonhereditary extraordinary interplanetary constabulary interdisciplinary cardiopulmonary multidisciplinary counterrevolutionary Words that almost rhyme with toothfairy
belly jelly smelly deli telly allele vermicelli underbelly heavy fairly semi heady faery sedgy veggie many ready healthy rarely steady barely petty levy penny fleshy levee messy sentry sexy sketchy sweaty vestry hefty jetty teddy bevy jenny thready kepi leggy recce scarcely wealthy deadly lengthy freshly gentry frenzy squarely carefree medley unfairly belfry deathly fleshly gayety halfpenny machete stealthy fidgety hostelry pebbly tempi testy breathy dressy pesky effendi lefty wetly already especially twenty assembly friendly gently plenty unhealthy densely antennae deftly spaghetti unsteady coquetry sullenly confetti tensely trendy deviancy directly correctly immensely excellency sacredly aplenty libretti maidenly marquetry adeptly ineptly preciously woodenly elementary expressly intensely epilepsy intently unfriendly apoplexy baronetcy reassembly indirectly incorrectly confusedly grotesquely catalepsy cognoscenti penitently complementary complexly narcolepsy ambivalently circumspectly equivalently