Here's what rhymes with supremaey.
they may day way say pay re lay j array bay gay k ray che hay nay weigh fay fe yea dey hey ley rei sei whey jay kc lei payee rea rj tae wei bey neigh cay fey roue shay moray away play stay clay essay gray grey obey pray okay prey repay sway tray fray oj slay allay ij ok sleigh bj bk drei fj replay tj tre zwei bray dray flay brae inveigh nisei prepay noway trey aurae spay aweigh today delay survey anyway convey decay spray ballet cafe stray runaway valet bouquet cliche fillet lamellae passe francais gangway naturae puree saute alleyway lingerie risque belay filet splay byplay pleurae purvey sachet toupee flyaway hooray urethrae briquet hurray layaway reweigh umbrae copay display everyday betray dismay halfway portray astray underway attache defray disarray disobey overlay papillae protege cabaret dossier emigre matinee microarray toothache underlay breakaway crochet croquet parquet sobriquet soiree souffle wordplay cabriolet fibulae hideaway ricochet throwaway airplay patellae resurvey sorbet soubriquet takeaway overpay roundelay sickbay medullae outplay outstay underpay bobsleigh misplay tearaway respray yesterday holiday interplay vertebrae communique faraway naivete passageway sequelae waterway nebulae societe getaway maxillae scapulae straightaway workaday caraway carriageway giveaway stingray stowaway underplay macrame overplay overstay caesurae uvulae copulae cybercafe foldaway penumbrae walkaway tarantulae formulae fistulae castaway companionway salmonellae trabeculae caravanserais