Here's what rhymes with preferye.
awry by my high why die lie thy y buy fly sky guy tie vi hi shy sigh bi bye chi dye fi hy nigh pi pie spy thai thigh vie dei fry ly psi quae rye sly ty wir hai lye mai muy nai wry cy fy kai lai luy mei sy tai thei wai phi sty stye slier apply dry supply try cry ply pry tri trie lullaby pri untie overlie aquae ossify spry amebae blowfly turfy lanai scurfy versify overbuy reply thereby deny justify rely hereby classify defy verify butterfly certify purify underlie alibi alveoli nullify pacify ratify unify belie pupae terrify amoebae crucify edify ramify resupply acidify bonsai deify firefly retry triply horrify overfly barfly mummify prettify shanghai drachmai ripply yuppify imply nearby occupy satisfy whereby clarify comply modify specify alkali signify testify glorify goodbye gratify notify amplify diversify rectify samurai beautify decry falsify termini typify codify descry dignify liquefy mollify oversupply personify vilify dragonfly mystify stratify vivify calcify emulsify misapply petrify reunify stupefy liquify scarify declassify vitrify beatify speechify banzais dandify identify stimuli multiply nuclei qualify simplify intensify fortify magnify standby solidify mortify demystify detoxify preoccupy stultify ultrahigh revivify dissatisfy hyperbolae refortify syllabify indemnify objectify electrify reclassify cumuli transmogrify gentrify solemnify exemplify quantify disqualify oversimplify misidentify