Here's what rhymes with payy.
                        
                        
                    
                                Words that almost rhyme with payy
highly  mighty  tiny  psyche  shiny  tidy  dryly  shyly  widi  wily  hyphae  wryly  limy  pricey  vilely  wiki  dicey  nightie  piney  piny  whiny  whitey  limey  nighty  siree  blimey  lichee  chivy  likely  widely  finely  lightly  lively  ninety  rightly  tightly  brightly  nicely  timely  wisely  nightly  knightly  slimy  spicy  blithely  grimy  slyly  spiny  feisty  flighty  spiky  wifely  chenille  sightly  smiley  stymie  lithely  showily  spiry  styli  ripely  skivvy  tritely  spryly  crikey  stripey  feistier  knightlier  sightlier  stymy  slightly  kindly  mildly  politely  wildly  blindly  divinely  almighty  sprightly  untidy  benignly  uprightly  snidely  vaginae  sprightlier  precisely  inquiry  unlikely  enquiry  untimely  unsightly  expiry  unwisely  sublimely  supinely  unsightlier  concisely  unkindly  contritely  impolitely  eruditely  bolsheviki  forthrightly  imprecisely