Here's what rhymes with payy.
Words that almost rhyme with payy
highly mighty tiny psyche shiny tidy dryly shyly widi wily hyphae wryly limy pricey vilely wiki dicey nightie piney piny whiny whitey limey nighty siree blimey lichee chivy likely widely finely lightly lively ninety rightly tightly brightly nicely timely wisely nightly knightly slimy spicy blithely grimy slyly spiny feisty flighty spiky wifely chenille sightly smiley stymie lithely showily spiry styli ripely skivvy tritely spryly crikey stripey feistier knightlier sightlier stymy slightly kindly mildly politely wildly blindly divinely almighty sprightly untidy benignly uprightly snidely vaginae sprightlier precisely inquiry unlikely enquiry untimely unsightly expiry unwisely sublimely supinely unsightlier concisely unkindly contritely impolitely eruditely bolsheviki forthrightly imprecisely