Here's what rhymes with naughtye.
by die buy tie bi bye dye pi pie thai dei ty tai my high why dry lie thy try y guy vi hi shy sigh chi fi hy nigh spy thigh vie ly ply psi quae rye wir awry hai lye mai muy nai pry tri trie wry cy fy kai lai luy mei pri sy thei wai phi sty stye apply cry fly sky deny nearby modify defy fry notify sly belie untie amoebae spry amebae turfy overbuy slier supply reply thereby imply occupy rely whereby hereby goodbye alibi decry pupae codify edify mollify mortify overlie aquae bonsai deify ossify retry lanai ripply banzais comply nuclei certify underlie fortify nullify pacify ratify samurai standby unify lullaby termini terrify typify descry ramify mystify triply blowfly horrify misapply stupefy overfly scurfy barfly mummify shanghai drachmai yuppify justify satisfy multiply qualify specify alkali signify testify verify butterfly glorify gratify purify quantify amplify magnify rectify beautify falsify dignify oversupply resupply vilify acidify firefly ultrahigh vivify petrify reunify versify prettify vitrify beatify speechify dandify identify stimuli clarify classify simplify alveoli diversify solidify crucify liquefy personify demystify preoccupy stratify stultify calcify emulsify cumuli liquify scarify hyperbolae gentrify refortify syllabify intensify indemnify objectify detoxify dragonfly electrify revivify dissatisfy declassify solemnify exemplify disqualify reclassify misidentify oversimplify transmogrify