Here's what rhymes with mayplay.
play re lay pray ray prey tray yea ley rei drei lei rea tre bray dray brae roue trey they may day way say pay delay j array bay clay gay gray grey k che hay nay spray weigh ballet stray fay fe fray slay allay dey hey sei sleigh whey bj bk jay kc payee rj tae tj wei bey flay neigh belay cay fey shay splay aurae away stay today decay essay obey okay betray repay sway astray oj valet bouquet defray fillet ij ok passe dossier fj naturae puree replay zwei parquet filet airplay byplay moray prepay purvey toupee hooray briquet hurray medullae outplay reweigh spay umbrae aweigh misplay display survey cafe dismay interplay portray attache cliche disarray overlay papillae cabaret emigre matinee nebulae saute underlay alleyway crochet croquet risque soiree souffle wordplay inveigh nisei patellae pleurae sachet sorbet soubriquet underplay noway overplay urethrae caesurae layaway outstay bobsleigh copay tearaway respray anyway convey everyday holiday halfway runaway underway vertebrae disobey faraway lamellae protege waterway francais gangway microarray toothache breakaway fistulae getaway lingerie maxillae sobriquet caraway fibulae hideaway ricochet throwaway resurvey stingray stowaway flyaway macrame overpay roundelay sickbay underpay copulae penumbrae yesterday formulae naivete passageway sequelae scapulae straightaway workaday cabriolet carriageway castaway giveaway takeaway overstay uvulae foldaway walkaway societe trabeculae salmonellae cybercafe tarantulae communique companionway caravanserais