Here's what rhymes with imlay.
re lay ray yea ley rei lei rea roue they may day way say pay play j array bay clay gay gray grey k pray che hay nay prey weigh tray fay fe fray slay allay dey hey sei sleigh whey drei jay kc payee rj tae tre wei bey bray dray flay neigh brae cay fey inveigh shay moray trey aurae away stay delay essay obey okay spray ballet betray repay stray sway oj valet defray fillet ij ok bj bk fj tj zwei belay filet splay nisei hooray noway hurray reweigh spay umbrae aweigh today display survey anyway convey decay cafe dismay interplay astray bouquet cliche disarray lamellae overlay passe dossier emigre gangway naturae puree replay saute underlay alleyway crochet croquet parquet risque soiree souffle airplay byplay prepay purvey sachet sorbet stingray toupee sickbay urethrae briquet layaway medullae outplay copay misplay everyday holiday halfway portray runaway underway attache disobey faraway papillae cabaret francais matinee microarray nebulae fistulae lingerie maxillae wordplay caraway fibulae giveaway ricochet throwaway patellae pleurae resurvey soubriquet underplay flyaway macrame overpay overplay roundelay caesurae outstay underpay bobsleigh penumbrae tearaway respray yesterday formulae vertebrae naivete protege sequelae waterway toothache breakaway getaway sobriquet workaday carriageway hideaway stowaway overstay uvulae copulae foldaway walkaway communique passageway societe scapulae straightaway cabriolet castaway salmonellae takeaway tarantulae trabeculae cybercafe companionway caravanserais