Here's what rhymes with hangnail.
male mail nail fail sale pale sail tail tale jail rail veil gale hail shale whale bail email vale wail bale dale pail quail snail hale quale kale grail faille wale scale trail avail entail frail stale assail curtail inhale fingernail flail braille gunwale mainsail unveil impale monorail carrell detail exhale bewail derail pigtail wassail pellmell hightail lugsail prevail travail ponytail topsail countervail foresail martingale taffrail bobtail nonpareil swallowtail tattletale