Here's what rhymes with fingerplay.
play re lay pray ray prey tray yea ley rei drei lei rea tre bray dray brae roue trey they may day way say pay delay j array bay clay gay gray grey k che hay nay spray weigh ballet interplay stray astray fay fe fray slay allay dey hey sei sleigh whey bj bk jay kc payee rj tae tj wei bey flay neigh belay cay fey shay splay aurae away stay today convey decay essay obey okay betray cafe repay sway oj valet bouquet defray fillet ij ok papillae passe cabaret dossier emigre fj puree replay zwei parquet filet airplay byplay moray patellae prepay purvey toupee underplay hooray overplay briquet hurray outplay reweigh spay umbrae aweigh misplay display survey dismay portray vertebrae attache cliche disarray lamellae overlay gangway naturae saute underlay alleyway crochet croquet fistulae getaway maxillae risque soiree souffle wordplay fibulae inveigh nisei pleurae sachet sorbet soubriquet stingray noway urethrae caesurae layaway medullae outstay bobsleigh copay copulae penumbrae tearaway respray anyway everyday holiday formulae halfway runaway underway disobey faraway passageway protege sequelae waterway francais matinee microarray nebulae toothache breakaway lingerie scapulae sobriquet workaday cabriolet caraway carriageway castaway giveaway hideaway ricochet throwaway resurvey stowaway flyaway macrame overpay overstay roundelay sickbay underpay yesterday communique naivete straightaway salmonellae takeaway uvulae cybercafe foldaway walkaway tarantulae societe companionway trabeculae caravanserais