Here's what rhymes with extremytye.
by die buy tie bi bye dye pi pie thai dei ty tai my high why dry lie thy try y guy vi hi shy sigh chi fi hy nigh spy thigh vie ly ply psi quae rye wir awry hai lye mai muy nai pry tri trie wry cy fy kai lai luy mei pri sy thei wai phi sty stye apply cry fly sky deny nearby defy fry sly belie untie amoebae spry amebae turfy slier supply reply thereby imply rely whereby hereby modify goodbye notify alibi standby unify decry lullaby pupae edify ramify aquae bonsai deify retry triply lanai prettify ripply banzais overbuy occupy stimuli clarify comply nuclei specify signify verify certify purify underlie nullify pacify ratify rectify samurai beautify solidify termini terrify typify codify descry dignify liquefy mollify mortify overlie resupply vilify firefly mystify ossify stratify vivify blowfly misapply reunify stupefy liquify scurfy barfly mummify shanghai drachmai solemnify yuppify identify justify satisfy multiply alkali classify simplify testify butterfly glorify gratify alveoli amplify fortify magnify falsify crucify personify acidify dragonfly preoccupy stultify ultrahigh horrify petrify revivify cumuli overfly scarify versify hyperbolae vitrify beatify gentrify refortify speechify syllabify dandify qualify exemplify intensify quantify diversify indemnify objectify oversupply demystify electrify calcify emulsify declassify oversimplify detoxify reclassify dissatisfy misidentify disqualify transmogrify