Here's what rhymes with exhortai.
                        
                        
                    
                                by  die  buy  tie  bi  bye  dye  pi  pie  thai  dei  ty  tai  my  high  why  dry  lie  thy  try  y  thereby  guy  vi  hereby  hi  shy  sigh  chi  fi  hy  nigh  spy  thigh  vie  ly  ply  psi  quae  rye  wir  awry  hai  lye  mai  muy  nai  pry  tri  trie  wry  cy  fy  kai  lai  luy  mei  pri  sy  thei  wai  phi  sty  stye  apply  cry  fly  reply  sky  deny  nearby  occupy  rely  whereby  defy  fry  goodbye  sly  alibi  fortify  belie  pupae  untie  retry  spry  amebae  horrify  turfy  lanai  ripply  slier  supply  imply  qualify  verify  glorify  ratify  decry  falsify  lullaby  amoebae  edify  mollify  mortify  vilify  aquae  bonsai  deify  ossify  triply  stupefy  scurfy  barfly  shanghai  banzais  overbuy  yuppify  clarify  comply  modify  nuclei  alkali  certify  gratify  notify  quantify  underlie  nullify  pacify  rectify  samurai  standby  unify  beautify  solidify  termini  terrify  typify  codify  descry  overlie  ramify  resupply  firefly  stratify  stultify  ultrahigh  vivify  blowfly  overfly  scarify  versify  prettify  vitrify  drachmai  speechify  syllabify  justify  satisfy  stimuli  multiply  specify  classify  signify  simplify  testify  butterfly  purify  alveoli  amplify  crucify  dignify  liquefy  oversupply  personify  acidify  mystify  preoccupy  calcify  misapply  petrify  reunify  cumuli  liquify  hyperbolae  mummify  beatify  refortify  dandify  identify  exemplify  diversify  magnify  disqualify  electrify  emulsify  revivify  gentrify  solemnify  intensify  indemnify  objectify  demystify  detoxify  dragonfly  reclassify  dissatisfy  declassify  oversimplify  misidentify  transmogrify