Here's what rhymes with careftilly.
chilly chile chili billy chilli dilly really silly hilly lily villi willy filly shabbily shrilly frilly gillie slily pithily sketchily lengthily patchily worthily healthily meagrely rockabilly sombrely stealthily waterlily tranquilly unworthily unhealthily involuntarily Words that almost rhyme with careftilly
cheery dearie teary beery deary theory weary dreary wiry bleary miry leery smeary busy pity dearly dimly dizzy sticky stiffly dinghy pithy bilge ditty jiffy picky piggy tinny bitchy bitty jimmy biddy biggie city nearly merely guilty pretty yearly chimney filthy guinea richly witty mini privy sickly thickly thinly tricky dingy fitly giddy gypsy kingly milky prickly silky skinny hippie silty stingy stringy tipsy filmy fishy kitty perigee pigmy pygmy sissy smithy spindly springy austerely finny frizzy gimme hippy kiddie ninny pinky primly shitty whinny dinky drizzly fizzy jitney middy pimply pinkie pixie prissy shimmy shinny stinky trimly clearly simply fifty quickly kidney severely strictly swiftly fiercely risky singly whiskey briskly grimly misty princely whisky windy flimsy thrifty feverishly glibly grisly gritty grizzly mitre bristly elastically flinty kinky limply lucidly nimbly shifty skimpy whimsy wispy frisky nifty pigsty quickie solidi weirdly clingy fifthly fluidly horridly rabidly slinky squishy twisty wimpy committee sixty sincerely wintry colicky crisply crudity intercity crispy deviltry menisci crinkly crushingly glitzy luridly swimmingly distinctly sophistry subcommittee fixedly ignominy languidly reentry sacristy synonymy cavalierly insincerely transitively succinctly unblushingly indistinctly propinquity indecisively