Here's what rhymes with butcherlie.
lie ly rye lye wry lai luy by my high why die dry thy try y buy cry fly guy tie vi hi shy sigh bi bye chi dye fi hy nigh pi pie thai thigh vie dei fry ply psi quae sly ty wir awry hai mai muy nai pry tri trie belie cy fy kai mei pri sy tai thei wai overlie phi turfy slier apply sky deny rely defy spy butterfly underlie alibi decry sty spry stye lanai overfly barfly banzais overbuy supply reply thereby imply nearby occupy whereby hereby alkali goodbye notify nullify pacify samurai lullaby pupae termini terrify typify untie codify descry edify mollify aquae bonsai deify firefly ossify retry triply amebae blowfly scurfy shanghai drachmai ripply justify comply modify nuclei qualify testify verify certify purify amplify fortify ratify standby unify beautify amoebae mortify oversupply ramify vilify stultify ultrahigh calcify horrify petrify stupefy versify hyperbolae mummify prettify beatify speechify dandify yuppify identify satisfy stimuli clarify multiply specify classify glorify gratify alveoli diversify magnify rectify falsify crucify dignify liquefy personify resupply acidify detoxify dragonfly mystify preoccupy stratify vivify emulsify misapply reunify liquify scarify vitrify gentrify signify simplify quantify disqualify solidify objectify demystify revivify cumuli dissatisfy declassify refortify syllabify intensify indemnify electrify reclassify solemnify exemplify oversimplify misidentify transmogrify