Here's what rhymes with athanael.
male mail nail fail sale pale sail tail tale avail jail rail veil gale hail shale whale bail email vale wail assail bale dale pail snail hale kale unveil faille wale scale trail entail frail stale curtail inhale quail flail quale braille gunwale grail impale hightail carrell detail travail fingernail bewail derail mainsail foresail monorail wassail pellmell hangnail lugsail prevail exhale pigtail ponytail topsail taffrail bobtail nonpareil countervail martingale swallowtail tattletale