Here's what rhymes with almyghtye.
by die buy tie bi bye dye pi pie thai dei ty tai my high why dry lie thy try y guy nearby vi hi shy sigh chi fi hy nigh spy thigh vie ly ply psi quae rye wir awry hai lye mai muy nai pry tri trie wry cy fy kai lai luy mei pri sy thei wai phi sty stye apply cry fly reply sky deny imply rely whereby hereby defy fry sly belie untie amoebae spry amebae turfy ripply overbuy slier supply thereby occupy modify goodbye notify alibi decry pupae termini typify edify overlie aquae bonsai deify mystify ossify retry triply misapply lanai banzais comply nuclei certify quantify underlie fortify nullify pacify ratify samurai standby unify lullaby terrify codify descry mollify mortify ramify vilify acidify vivify blowfly horrify stupefy overfly scurfy barfly mummify prettify shanghai vitrify drachmai yuppify justify satisfy multiply qualify specify alkali signify simplify testify verify butterfly glorify gratify purify amplify magnify rectify beautify falsify solidify dignify liquefy oversupply personify resupply demystify firefly ultrahigh petrify reunify liquify versify beatify gentrify refortify speechify dandify identify stimuli clarify classify intensify alveoli diversify indemnify crucify detoxify electrify preoccupy stratify stultify calcify emulsify revivify cumuli dissatisfy scarify hyperbolae syllabify exemplify objectify dragonfly reclassify declassify misidentify solemnify disqualify oversimplify transmogrify