Here's what rhymes with ahay.
they say hay fay fe hey sei fey shay may day way away pay re lay stay j survey array bay essay gay k ray che nay weigh cafe sway fray slay yea allay dey ley passe rei sleigh whey fj jay kc lei payee rea rj tae wei zwei bey flay neigh cay roue purvey sachet spay aweigh play today clay convey decay gray grey obey pray okay prey spray ballet stray tray astray oj valet attache fillet ij ok bj bk drei saute tj tre bray dray brae filet inveigh splay moray nisei hooray trey urethrae aurae hurray delay dismay halfway repay bouquet cliche defray disarray overlay dossier francais crochet parquet risque soiree souffle belay ricochet resurvey sorbet toupee noway overpay overstay sickbay layaway outstay reweigh umbrae copay display anyway everyday holiday betray runaway underway disobey faraway lamellae naivete papillae protege waterway cabaret emigre gangway naturae puree replay toothache underlay alleyway croquet getaway lingerie maxillae workaday caraway giveaway hideaway throwaway airplay byplay patellae prepay soubriquet stowaway flyaway overplay briquet caesurae medullae outplay underpay bobsleigh misplay tearaway respray yesterday interplay portray vertebrae passageway sequelae matinee nebulae societe breakaway fistulae sobriquet wordplay castaway fibulae pleurae stingray takeaway underplay macrame uvulae copulae cybercafe foldaway walkaway formulae microarray scapulae straightaway carriageway roundelay penumbrae communique cabriolet salmonellae tarantulae trabeculae caravanserais companionway