Here's what rhymes with afterrail.
male fail mail sale pale sail tail tale trail jail nail rail veil gale hail shale whale bail vale wail bale dale pail hale braille kale faille wale detail scale avail entail frail email stale assail quail snail flail quale bewail derail grail pellmell hightail prevail travail curtail inhale exhale pigtail topsail unveil foresail impale taffrail bobtail wassail carrell gunwale mainsail ponytail martingale monorail nonpareil hangnail lugsail fingernail countervail swallowtail tattletale